Sign Up for Email News

  • CommuterPageBlog and CommuterPage.com
    Sign up to receive new blog posts by email. You can also choose to receive current stories from local news sources about biking, walking, Metro, local bus systems, and more.

Google Search

  • Search
    Google

    WWW
    commuter.typepad.com
Powered by TypePad

« Biking, Busing and Taking the Train | Main | Montreal Shows Bike-Sharing Can Go Big Time in North America »

May 18, 2009

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d83451f42669e201157091d141970b

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Making Cycling Easy - the Dutch Experience:

Comments

Paul DeMaio

I disagree with your thesis, Allen. "Mechanized walking", as you described it, is driving a car. Bicycling, regardless of whether it's done by a tricycle, electric-assist cycle, unicycle, or bicycle, is all bicycling. Your stance against individuals who cycle because their governments have been successful in creating an urban environment where cycling is the easiest and best option is confounding and misguided.

Where I do agree with you is that more expensive and inconvenient driving will "push" bicycling use. But at the same time, safer and more bicycling infrastructure that people of all ages feel safe using - not just the least risk-adverse cyclists around - is the key to providing the "pull" of encouraging cycle use.

Allen Muchnick

The bicycling described here is mechanized walking. While I don't object to such bicycling per se, it's only feasible as a significant transportation mode where 1) driving and parking an automobile is expensive and inconvenient and 2) many destinations are within walking distances.

In Europe, the expense and inconvenience of using an automobile for local urban trips first forces many to stop driving. Then, these non-motorists realize that slow bicycling is faster than walking.

Until driving and parking an auto in U.S. urban centers becomes costly and inconvenient, very few people will use bicycles as in Holland and Denmark, regardless of how much "bicycle infrastructure" the government provides.

Today, ample and free (or highly subsidized) auto parking remains a central feature of Arlington's "urban village" redevelopment.

The comments to this entry are closed.

CommuterPage.com Commuter News